Vietnam revisited by a revisionist

Conclusion: By interfering, the USA was responsible in causation for the deaths of (correction 3)–5.1 million Vietnamese, give or take a few.
So endeth the sermon by Peter at Lavartus Prodeo. Argueing from a lawyers viewpoint he posts an article with the sole purpose of sheeting the blame for an inflated casualty rate on the US. I have just attended a reunion of the 7th Battalion, The Royal Australian Regiment at Fremantle in Western Australia and can only express amazement at Peter’s naivity, or is it blinded ignorance? On the Indian Pacific a fellow traveller asks me why I was going to Perth, I mention the reunion and he says ah yes, Vietnam…such a waste. I enlighten him and for the first time in his lifer he thinks beyond the 10 second audio visual bites he was fed on the evening news. I tell him we who fought it don’t think it a waste. At the very least we stemmed the flow of the scourge of communism for a decade and depleted the coffers of the USSR and Communist China to such an extent that the events that lead to the fall of the Berlin War were set in train. Millions escaped after the fall of Saigon by boat, by plane, by anything that would remove them from the hell that was coming. Millions didn’t. Lefties still mintain the soft view of Ho Chi Minh that portays him as a nationalist with his only intention being to rid Vietnam of the French and later, the US, when from day one he was a marxist, schooled by the Soviets to take over both South and North Vietnam to form a communist bastion in the east. To view a ten year war through the statutes of law seems a strange approach to me. I see men in suits arguening the case but the backdrop, the rear wall of the court room, is enscribed with millions of names of men who died and all Peter can do is argue for the aggressors. The communists invaded; the Free World forces tried to defend. Maybe Peter was around when the war was on but somehow I doubt it. I was there and went back a couple of years ago to view first hand the results of 30 plus years of communism. The economy has been comatozed for decades and is just showing some life now the old Marxists are dying and losing power. Yet the people have a shadow over them of the millions who have disappeared or are still alive but shattered by re-education camps. Over the road from the bar I frequented a family lives on the profit from selling a dozen or so soft drinks per day…..in 2004. How can educated men defend this? School, Uni, Law School, employment with Smith, Smith and Smith, see the world through a law book. Never touch the dead just count them and use the stats to put a fallacious arguement. Makes it all worthwhile, doesn’t it?

Citizen Tests

A PLAN to check English fluency and Australian values as part of a citizenship test for prospective immigrants has been blasted by politicians and ethnic groups. Sounds good to me. I have no problems with the premise that aspiring immigrants should be able to communicate with us and understand a little of what we are about. It makes their transition to our culture so much easier. Senator Nettle, espousing the standards of some obscure ideology or country other than Australia doesn’t agree;
She says: “A fluent grasp of English is not a prerequisite of being Australian.
Maybe not but I can see things being a whole lot easier for immigrants if it was; and
“Has Mr Robb forgotten that many Indigenous Australians do not speak fluent English? Is he suggesting that they are less Australian?
He isn’t suggesting any such thing you silly woman but I suggest not having english is a part of the problem of the many indigenous Australians you refer to and besides,the fact that someone in Australia isn’t fluent in english is not an arguement to not try and get everyone up to standard.

More on Hill 82

In November I posted a piece on two of my friends from pre-Vietnam Army days who died in Vietnam and still lie there. The post noted how a Jim Burke had located the scene of the contact and was looking for support to close the search and bring the boys home.

Jim’s plea for help had borne fruit with the Government coming to the party.

The Australian Government has approved a grant of $37,500 for Operation Aussies Home to search for likely burial sites of two Australian soldiers killed in action during the Vietnam War, the Minister Assisting the Minister for Defence Bruce Billson, said today.

The full notice from Defence Media is over the page Continue reading »

Instant ‘Sacred Site’ created in Melbourne

An indigenous activist/malcontent with some gripe against the country talks about an illegal camp, sacred site set up in Kings Domain, Melbourne.

This though, is a home and a symbol. And that sacred fire over there is a living conduit to the Creator. You don’t mess with that.

Maybe not, but someone sure as hell has messed with his brain.

I know it’s almost passé to say it but if a white fellow lit a fire in the Kings Domain he would be sent packing by the constabulary and invited to discuss the matter with the Magistrate should we have been so bold as to argue the matter. The Age wouldn’t have bothered reporting the incident but get a fellow with victim pigmentation involved and they’re all over it.

Melbourne bylaws forbid camping in public parkland, but the authorities are caught in a cleft: they are being lambasted on talkback radio for inaction, but news vision of a forcible removal of the campers would give them the oxygen of more publicity and perhaps attract more activists — of all stripes.

So remove them at 2.00 in the morning after having doused the living conduit to the creator with a bucket of water, half consumed goonies or whatever comes to hand.

Robbie, this weeks token victim, then threatens us with wasting our money as well as our time.

And there’s always white man magic, he notes, smiling. “If they come to kick us out, we’ll wait and see the documentation — and then we’ve got a whole army of lawyers in Collins Street just waiting to have a go at them.”

Taxpayer funded Legal Aid no doubt.

Aborigines to be paid only one-third

Annabelle McDonald in the Australian reports some shocking news
ABORIGINAL cultural heritage workers in Queensland will be paid about a third of the amount white people earn for performing similar roles, under a controversial ruling by the state’s Land and Resources Tribunal.
Well, on the face of it, it is shocking news but my life experiences lead me to a different conclussion. In 2004 I visited the Northern Territory and the Gulf country of Queensland and while there came across cultural heritage workers. At Gregory River I spoke to a Telstra manager who was charged with laying a optic fibre network for the local Aborigines. I quote from an article I wrote at the time.
Mick, (not his real name) the Telstra manager, told us horror stories of dealing with the local indigenous population. Cultural monitors demand $300 per day for their presence at any work site. Once the monitors on any Telstra job exceed 6 then there is a Cultural Monitor Supervisor who gets paid in excess of a $1,000 per day to make sure the monitors are doing their job. Telstra are expected to have an Archeologist on site as well and he is charged with ensuring the Optic Fibre lines are not desecrating culturally significant sites. Stories of the Archeologist picking up a rock and saying… “This looks like an old axe? or whatever, and the monitor saying “Is it? Oh yeah, so it is. You fellows have to go around? Ah, such science. Four D11 dozers are used on an optic fibre line. One to clear the scrub, one to level the path, one to rip the trench and one to fill. These things cost thousands of dollars per day so I would hate to think of the costs associated with rerouting the line a kilometre or two around a culturally significant piece of rock.
I don’t think it’s quiet the racist issue Annabelle would have us believe and I just wonder, for the record, what similar roles do white cultural heritage workers get involved in?

Cartoonist fails Diplomacy 101

If Australia was gaining any ascendency in the Great Cartoon debate we lost it with Bill Leaks answering Rakyat Merdeka’s grubby effort depicting Howard and Downer in sexual union with a equally grubby cartoon depicting SBY doing something similar to the West Papuans. Bill , in a satirical piece in todays Australian asks;WHY is it that us cartoonists are copping so much flak lately? Because some of your cartoons offend people, that’s why, but then you already know that Bill, it’s how you sell copy. Satire, all to often an excuse for stating ones opinion under the guise of poor taste, doesn’t answer the critics and all the cartoon has done is made it more difficult for Howard and Downer to placate the Indonesians over the Papuan refugees. It’s difficult enough as it is without undergrad humour. Trying to bring some sense into the debate PM Howard tries to defuses the debate saying;
(He was)  optimistic yesterday that Australian-Indonesian relations would survive the rift over Papua, as Australians rallied in four cities to support the Papuan cause for independence from Jakarta. 
I’m not sure supporting the Free West Papua movement is the way to go at the moment.  Better to keep encouraging the Indonesians to  be reasonable in their handling of the area.   I’m further convinced it’s a  no-win situation when I read Senator Bob Brown addressed the rally.  If he’s involved whatever he suggests won’t be in anyones interest.  I note in other sources that the Indonesians have refused to give Greens Senator Kerry Nettle a visa to visit.   Good move. Bob Brown is quotes as saying;
“If the Howard Government’s repeated calls for liberty and democracy around the world are not hollow, then it must act to ensure one million West Papuans get liberty and democracy,” Senator Brown said. 
Long on Howard bashing yet decidedly short on suggestions as to just how Australia might force Indonesia to give West Papuans liberty and democracy.  What does Bob mean by liberty and democracy…Independance? ….another East Timor? No wonder the Indonesians are cranky with loose cannons like Brown suggesting in a public arena that Australia should ensure anything relating to what are after all, peoples of a sovereign government.  Let the diplomats encourage the Indons to lift their game without making public statements that could be construed as interefering threats.

AWB continues to feed fantasies

A lot of Labor supporters and assorted Howard haters are depending on the Cole Commission to bring about the decline of the Howard Government. I’m sure Caroline Overington’s latest expose crashes from a leader of “Cole orders Downer to reveal all” to senior counsel, John Agius SC quoted as We have written to them and asked them for statements,” he said. “If I need to call them, I will” in three short paragraphs. The Australian editorial asks alot of questions but the public are wearying and are starting to ask whether Canberra can get on with governing the country rather than spend a lot of energy looking for someone to hang over the AWB doing what it was charged with doing – selling wheat. I’ve seldom witnessed such a storm over an inquiry before the findings are published. The bizarre episode this week where it was revealed that Howard and Cole shared the same Alma Mater and had both been present at a reunion is just an indication of how desparate the anti-conservative groups are. They can’t get within cooee of the government on things that matter like fiscal management, interest rates,unemployment or defence and yet they pontificate about “fees” when the whole counry knows, or should know, that corporations and businesses have done the same thing under Labor governments. As a general bench mark, if the ABC and the SBS are heavily into a subject then the general public aren’t; likewise, if the readership and comments on Lavartus Prodeo are going beserk over a subject then you can bet all the dollars paid in “fees” that the public’s attention is elsewhere. I’ll pass soon. The inquiry will finish, Cole will make a submission and if there are steps to be taken then that will happen. In the meantime, it’s all wishfull thinking. The hardest aspect to call is listing every player’s agenda. Some, like the ALP, simply want the keys to the treasury, I presume the Australian wants Downer out of the picture; The US Wheat farmers want more trade and the local wheat farmers are split between wanting a single desk sales mechanism or their own personal interest sales mechanism in place. Interesting theatre but I’m waiting for the final act. I think several players and organizations are going to be dissapointed – at least I hope they are.

Legacy

History Under the Hammer. I have been busy with the Brisbane Legacy Auction that we run every year to raise funds to support the widows and children of deceased Australian war veterans. Following is an extract from Brisbane Legacy’s E-news.

AuctionImagine owning your own piece of military history – a 400-year-old Samurai sword, rare uniforms, Nazi books and equipment or Army, Naval and Airforce memorabilia, from pre-Federation to today’s Defence Force.

All that and more is on offer at Brisbane Legacy’s Militaria Auction on the 2nd of April.

Having grown to become Queensland’s premier Militaria Auction, the event is expected to bring hundreds of Militaria enthusiasts and collectors from all over Queensland and other states around Australia, some as far as Adelaide.

Brisbane Legacy Researcher for the auctions, Mr Kevin Gillett, says the Auctions attract a wide variety of collectors and an even greater variety of memorabilia.

“Collectors regularly travel from as far as Northern Queensland, New South Wales and Victoria to attend the event. At the Auction in October last year we had a whole family travel across from Perth just to extend their collection of rare WW1 and WW2 Medals?

“This year we’ve received a very diverse array of over 400 items. We have a collection of over 20 Japanese swords, over 20 shell cases from WW1 to Vietnam, a 1938 copy of Mein Kampf, rare uniforms including an Australian WW2 AWAS uniform and a NSW Pre-Federation Military Forces uniform and even Nazi dinnerware?

Also at the Auction is a Militaria stall selling a huge variety of bargain priced memorabilia.

“The stall runs on Saturday and Sunday and contains over 1000 items. Lots of Military training pamphlets, books, uniforms and other memorabilia is available for direct sale at bargain prices?

The popularity of the auction helps raise over $20,000 for the widows and children of Legacy.

If you are interested in attending the Auction there is a viewing on Saturday April 1st from 10am to 2pm.

The Auction itself starts at 10am on Sunday with viewing available from 8:30am.

If you would like more information on the Militaria Auction, would like to volunteer to help at the Auction or would like to be e-mailed a catalogue E-Mail here or contact Legacy on 1800 534 229(freecall) for more details.

…………………………………

Not only am I the ‘Researcher’ but I manage the database, function as date entry bloke and produce the website. A usual I am also running behind time but by late this evening I will have the website up and running. After, say 1800hrs AEST, visit here for a full catalogue. If you are into owning very old and significant pieces of Australia’s (and sometimes, our enemies) military history then do visit.

Regular readers would be well aware of my military background and thus would not be surpised that I support Legacy. I consider it a sacred trust to help widows and children of our fallen servicemen but in the world of volunteer workers too few answer the call. If you are of the more community spirited type of person, not necessarily ex military, but would like to help others then email me or leave a comment. We are currently restricted to one auction year due to lack of support. I am looking for MS Access managers, data entry help, and volunteers to help catalogue, identify, value and tag items for next years auction. (or another auction later this year if I actually get volunteers) The peak period lasts for about two weeks prior to the Auction day.

Swamp me with offers of support….NOW

Larry

I’ve been waiting for someone to have sufficient bad manners to compare Larry with Katrina – didn’t take too long. Over at LP Kate raises the issue thus giving readers a platform to vent their spleen against Bush. It’s all about Aid to the Civil Power. In a national disaster the authorities from the local government up have to request help from the Federal government before the Military etc can be deployed. In Queensland’s case the Mayor at Innisfail and the Premier of Queensland were obviously well versed in the procedure and acted accordingly. In Katrina’s case the Mayor and Governer seemed to be ideological incompetants and procrastinated over decisions. There are other obvious differences; the first being the relative sizes of Larry and Katrina and Innisfail and New Orleans. Still, gives them a chance to put down on Bush again. Ian Gerard, in the Australian sees the glass half empty as he finds problems in the relief work;
In a sign that the relief effort is struggling to cope with Cyclone Larry’s aftermath, the most powerful cyclone to hit the Queensland coast in more than 80 years, tempers flared as a large crowd waited in torrential rain.
And John Howard was jeered at first but later earnt applause;
John Howard was initially jeered in Innisfail when he arrived yesterday, but was later cheered when he announced $10,000 tax-free grants for small businesses and $200,000 low-interest loans to allow local businesses and farmers whose crops were wiped out to rebuild.
Yeah…right. Waiting in the relief queue outside the Innisfail courthouse yesterday was Shiralee Hazel;
She expressed the frustration of many: “Effing do something now. That is my message for them. Get off their fat arses and do something.”
They are off their fat arses, Shiralee. The Disaster Coordination Centre in Brisbane was functioning days before Larry hit Innisfail; the military were on standby at Lavarack Barracks waiting for road access before they despatched hundreds of trucks all loaded with gear ready to help. The Army doesn’t load these trucks post the event -they were loading while the North was getting flattened. Green painted water purifcation and desalination plant are in situ now as are kitchens to help feed the locals who have lost their kitchens. The Army Blackhawkes have been there helping and the RAAF have been doing photo runs with F11s to asses the damage further out. RAAF Hercules aircraft from Sydney have flown in hundreds of tarps and other supplies. The Power authorities had vehicles load with sufficient cabling to recable complete towns and generators to power up water and sewerage pumping stations prior to the full disclosure of the damage. They left Brisbane as soons as roads were opened. Power and Telstra crews were in working on the afternoon of the day of the disaster. State Emergency Services local crews were working that day as well helping other locals as they tried to make sense of their lives and hundreds of volunteer crews are heading to the area and a lot are already there. I listened to radio yesterday and the day before and noted the admirable work being done by dozens of agencies as the announcer spoke to them all. He was actually in situ and interviewed soldiers as the headed North from Townsville. It was all good and as it should be. Everyone he spoke to just wanted to get there and help restore people’s lives. I have empathy for Shiralee but the fact that she was in a queue the day after Larry struck fully expecting to get a cash handout suggests to me that the public servants were off their arses as well. Personally, I think Ian Gerard has denigrated the work of everyone involved by quoting some stressed out woman in a queue. Maybe, just maybe, he could go further afield and talk to the majority of locals who are thankfull for any help they are getting. Of course, while all this is going on the rain continues to bucket down flooding access roads and communities and slowing a lot of relief work but you can see on TV that the Australians who are there to help are not stopped by this – they continue to strive. When the news of the disaster struck I was instantly over the Commonwealth Games and looked for full-on TV coverage of the relief work. Not to be; Australians are suffering and we sit and watch pampered athletes win gold and subsequent lucrative endoresments. The heroes are up in Innisfail working in appalling conditions, often on a voluntary status (no financial reward), against nature at her worst only to be told to get off their respective arses.

Operation Larry Assist

Just in from the ADF Media Centre.  Brisbane media report Queensland requested Federal aid at 1400 hrs yesterday. As everyone knows, including the media rabble involved in Katrina in New Orleans, Federal governments cannot react to emercencies until officially requested to do so by State authorities. Thus; Defence has reacted swiftly to requests for support from the Queensland Government as part of the Commonwealth Disaster Plan in the aftermath of Cyclone Larry. The ADF has mounted Operation Larry Assist, which is commanded by Brigadier Michael Slater, the Commander of 3 Brigade based in Townsville, to coordinate ADF assistance. The ADF has provided the following support after receiving requests from Emergency Management Australia (EMA): * Brigadier Slater completed a low-level aerial reconnaissance of the affected area in a Navy Seahawk helicopter on Monday afternoon. * Late Monday evening Brigadier Slater deployed a Combat Service Support Team via road to the Innisfail Show Grounds. The team consists of the following:
o  A Field Kitchen with fresh rations to sustain 200 people for 24 hours.
o 10 Unimog trucks with 9000 litres of water and ration packs.
o 60 tarpaulins for emergency shelter.
o 5 person Primary Healthcare Team.
o Water Storage Capability.
o Environmental Health Officers.
* Early this morning Brigadier Slater deployed an Engineer Group with a water purification unit capable of producing 7500 litres per hour, and an Infantry Company of around 100 personnel to provide general assistance. * An Air Force C-130 Hercules will transport tarpaulins and other stores provided by the NSW State Emergency Service and private sources from RAAF Base Richmond to Innisfail later today. * A Sea King and one Seahawk helicopter will deploy to Townsville from the Nowra Naval Air Station later today. * Further support, under consideration by EMA, that may be requested from the ADF includes:
o Provision of food and water.
o Provision of shower facilities at the three evacuation sites.
o Provision of bedding for up to 500 people within the shire. The ADF has a Navy Seahawk helicopter and Army Blackhawk helicopter standing by in the local area to continue to provide support. 
o Additional Air Force Hercules and Caribou aircraft and Navy landing craft are also available for tasking on request.
The ADF has considerable experience and expertise in providing humanitarian assistance to post disaster recovery support both in Australia and abroad. Damm right it has and we should be thankful but peope like Bryan Law in Townsville will most probably still complain about the noise of the choppers on the way to Innisfail.
1 9 10 11 12 13 36